November 18, 2026 09:03 PM

Just One in 510 Applicants Wins an Affordable Housing Apartment in New York City

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Print

Getting an affordable apartment through New York City’s housing lottery has become increasingly difficult, with only one family securing a rental unit for every 510 applications submitted on average.

Between January 2022 and October 2024, the city’s Housing Connect system received 10,250,872 applications, but only 20,200 families signed rental agreements, according to a government data analysis by The City.

The analysis found significant differences in lottery success rates across income groups. For a four-member household, the odds were approximately one in 639 for low-income applicants, one in 325 for moderate-income applicants and one in 398 for upper-middle-income applicants.

The distribution of available apartments also highlights the challenges facing the poorest households. From July 2020 to November 2, 2026, Housing Connect advertised 56,271 apartments, but only 4 per cent were designated for extremely low-income families. By comparison, 39 per cent were allocated to moderate-income households.

Local residency preferences also have a major impact on applicants’ chances. Residents of the community district where a housing development is located have approximately a one-in-53 chance of securing an apartment. Without this preference, the odds fall to one in 1,051.

Being selected in the lottery does not guarantee an apartment. Applicants must still pass income, household-size and document verification. Applications may be rejected if information does not match eligibility requirements. Some selected applicants also turn down apartments because of rent levels or other considerations.

Affordable housing opportunities are unevenly distributed across the city. Areas such as Long Island City, Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Downtown Brooklyn and South Bronx have seen comparatively more apartment developments. In contrast, several neighborhoods in Staten Island, along with Laurelton, Rosedale and Queens Village, have fewer lottery opportunities.

Experts say the central problem is the widening gap between demand for affordable housing and the available supply. Although the lottery follows established rules, thousands of families continue applying year after year without securing suitable homes.

For many New York residents, finding affordable housing has increasingly become a matter of chance rather than a reliable path to stable accommodation.

Subscribe our YouTube channel